I'm an NPR junkie (via internet radio and podcasts) and was listening to "Talk of the Nation" last night...
Click for iTunes versionor
go here to listen on their site
At the end of the show they had a segment about Virginia apologizing (or expressing "regret") for having practiced slavery. The discussion was about whether this apology was a necessary thing to do and if the federal government should do something similar.
Chels and I had a good discussion about this and I just wanted to throw it out to everyone. As of now I'm certainly not opposed to a general apology or expression of regret that our nation practiced slavery but I don't somehow feel personal regret. It's more of a "I'm sorry that humans do stupid things" kind of feeling. Aside from a line from a Cherokee great grandmother, I'm not sure I have any roots that go that far back in the U.S. and even if I did I don't feel any sort of need to apologize as a Caucasian. I had nothing to do with it and those it was perpetrated against are all long past.
Is there continued prejudice and bigotry continuing from slavery and before? Obviously and I think
that is something worth fighting today. Here in Utah, and the west in general, ridiculous prejudice against Latinos abounds and it is embarrassing that this is an issue among humans.
In the program it is discussed whether this apology is just lip service and, if so, is some kind of further recompense appropriate? One guest makes an analogy of getting a messed up hair cut and getting your money back. I think this analogy is poor because no one can literally say "you bought me and treated me like crap so I want payback". So, I personally disagree with any kind of direct reparations to individuals. What about other efforts like Affirmative Action?
Affirmative Action or positive discrimination is a sticky issue. As most would agree there are continued negative effects and barriers due to past racist policies. One of which is difficulty breaking free from a cycle of poverty. Does Affirmative Action effectively target these barriers? That's tough for me to answer. I don't find much issue with more scholarships and efforts to increase education being given to minorities or groups that have been historically repressed. A leg up can help break through a perpetual cycle and set a precedent. Hopefully most of these kinds of efforts can be payed for by private organizations but the government also being involved doesn't bother me.
Anyway, we were talking about these kinds of things and since I haven't been over to Harmon's forever to vent (and he seems to miss the blog) I'll post it up here.
Have a listen and discuss amongst yourselves.